Ice Cream Pints

Dairy Free Ice Cream

Sammies & Pops

Foxtrot Ice Cream

Local Favorites

Tasty ice cream from Jeni's and other top brands - get the best flavors, delivered quickly to your door.

Ice Cream

Woman-Owned

Real bananas, ultra-rich coconut cream, and scratch-made vanilla wafers. Vegan. Gluten-free. Dairy-free.

This is a mouthful of richness and texture. With an explosion of real banana and a touch of coconut, it's an almost-tropical reprieve with zero-gravity texture. If you're going dairy-free, this is the one to convert you.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Dairy-Free Banana Cream Pudding

Mackenzie Creamery’s hormone-free goat cheese, with sweet-tart bright red cherries. Mixed into Jeni's famous grass-grazed dairy ice cream.

Hands down Mackenzie Creamery makes the best goat cheese. The Northeast Ohio small-batch and family-run creamery churns out naturally tangy goat cheese with strong, fresh flavor and a clean finish. So they married it with their grass-grazed dairy for a light and tangy ice cream as satisfyingly rich as a dense cheesecake. The cherry on top? From-scratch, deep-red sauce made with a mix of fresh Michigan cherries and sugar-plumped dried cherries for a sweet-tart fruitiness more intense than ever.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Goat Cheese with Red Cherries

Homemade banana custard (made with real bananas, no flavoring) with small-batch brandy, caramel sauce, and burnt sugar candies.

The intersection of Bananas Foster and crème brûlée is this pint. A silky egg yolk custard and torched sugar candies pay homage to the French dessert, while a splash of apple brandy (made with Ohio apples by Watershed Distillery) create a new spin.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Brandied Banana Brulee

Intelligentsia coffee steeped in cream for a robust, earthy, coffee-infused ice cream with an undercurrent of caramel.

This is like if walking down the coffee aisle of the grocery store was an ice cream, but with Jeni's superior slow-churned perfection and richness.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Coffee with Cream and Sugar

Milk Bar's handmade, gourmet ice cream has an ultra-creamy base of Chocolate B’Day cake-flavored ice cream, topped with chocolate B’Day crumbs, chocolate cake batter, and B’Day frosting.

It's like they took their most popular Birthday flavor and upped the ante. Called “one of the best bakeries” by Bon Appetit, Milk Bar has been reinventing delicious baked goods since 2008—and now we're replacing our store-bought birthday cakes with them.

Milk Bar Ice Cream - Chocolate Birthday Cake

Ben & Jerry's famously delicious chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream, made dairy free with almond milk.

Even dairy lovers will love this pint. Just grab a spot on the couch, one extra large spoon, and have yourself an old-fashioned TV binge.

Ben & Jerry's - Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Bites

Chocolatey chunks of cookie dough swirled into creamy vanilla ice cream.

Here’s a little history lesson for you: Back in 1984, two guys from Vermont had the right idea to mix cookie dough into vanilla ice cream, resulting in the world’s first batch of chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream. Over thirty years later, it reigns supreme as one of the brand’s most popular concoctions. It’s perfect for those times when you kinda want ice cream, but kinda need a cookie as well.

Ben & Jerry's - Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Bites

Founded in 2002, Jeni Britton Bauer set out to craft artisan ice cream using whole ingredients and dairy from grass-pastured cows, sparking a movement in frozen desserts more than a decade before it would become a top food trend.

Jeni's Ice Cream

Jeni's limited edition Holiday lineup is back! Made with the flavor that inspired Jeni to make ice cream! A classic combination of velvety milk chocolate cream, Vietnamese cinnamon, and cayenne.

This is what made Jeni drop out of art school and pursue ice cream. The deeply milky, almost bouncy chocolate ice cream acts as the perfect base to red-hot cayenne. It's the definition of sweet heat, inspired by the classic drink, and we're stoked to have it again.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Mexican Hot Chocolate

Jeni's limited edition Holiday lineup is back! Made with pure, roasted pistachio cream with a savory finish and nugat-like honey texture.

Jeni has always been told this flavor tastes like a perfect, pistachio green French macaron cookie. Freshly ground, roasted pistachios infuse the milk and cream with toasty nuttiness. A little honey for mystical, meringue-like texture. A touch of almond extract makes every other ingredient pop.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Pistachio Macaron

Jeni's limited edition Holiday lineup is back! Made with a swirl of pink and white peppermint with white chocolate freckles.

The crowd favorite is back. Have you ever wondered what a winter wonderland tastes like? Because it's brisk, glittered in peppermint, flecked in white chocolate, and is akin to skating on a smooth frozen-over pond.

Jeni's Ice Cream - White Chocolate Peppermint

Jeni's limited edition Holiday lineup is back! Made with brown sugar-oat crisp, cranberries, and walnuts wrapped in lively cranberry cream.

Tart, sweet, and nutty come together to make a flavorful symmetry we didn't know possible. Cranberries are a forgotten holiday flavor, but this silky scoop brings them centerstage to pair with your post-supper coffee, brandy, or cheese board.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Cranberry Crumble

Jeni's limited edition Holiday lineup is back! Made with silky egg custard, spiked with nutmeg, and some Uncle Nearest whiskey.

Picture that handmade, small-batch eggnog recipe from your town's holiday street festival, but in a gourmet ice cream. Jeni's fireside favorite returns so it's best to snag a pint before we buy them all ourselves. Just giving you a heads up.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Boozy Eggnog

A layered custom pint of buttercream, blackberry, lemon, and cake pieces.

Not your average facade of fondant and wedding-clad figurines. Like wedding season itself, this pint sings to summertime.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Wedding Cake

A summery golden sweet cream with cloves, toffee, turmeric, vanilla, and ylang-ylang mixed in. A limited flavor as part of Jeni's Ice Cream Truck Collection.

This amber colored gem won't be here for too long, so we're taking this deliciously delicious golden 'scream to all the summer parties. Trust us, you've never had something this aromatic and custard-like before.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Golden Nectar

Sun-popped popcorn mixed into rich and creamy vanilla ice cream. Topped with toffee for a caramel, decadent flavor in every spoonful. Tastes like summer, only sweeter.

This tastes like state fairs, beach days, and movie nights all in one. Striving to continuously improve, Jeni’s buys directly from their sources because they believe good relationships make good products. Matched with an even greater imagination, this ice cream quite simply slaps.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Butterscotch Popcorn

Rich double vanilla ice cream with gooey fudge swirled-in, and chunks of chocolate-covered waffle cone pieces.

You don't have to sacrifice the crunch of the ice cream cone experience just 'cause it's in a pint container. It's a deconstructed, fudge-swirled vanilla ice cream cone, but the cone is also encased in chocolate.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Bombastix Sundae Cone

A tart, sour watermelon candy, but in ice cream form. Plenty of citric acid gives this creamy dessert the right amount of pucker. Enjoy a scoop on its own, or in a sundae or float.

Jeni’s wants one thing: to make the best ice cream they can. Striving to continuously improve, they buy directly from their sources because they believe good relationships make good products. The result is the perfect summer cool-down.

Jeni's Ice Cream - Watermelon Taffy

Strawberry Italian ice made with real strawberries! Sweetened with plant-based erythritol and monkfruit. Zarlengo's has been serving handmade, family-owned gelato and Italian ice in Chicagoland since 1983.

Picture it. A hot coastal day in Italy. The sea spray in your hair, the seagulls faintly in your ear, as you sit on a sun-drenched terracotta patio with one of these in your hand to cool you down.

Zarlengo's Italian Ice Pop - Strawberry

Mango Italian ice made with real fruit. Zarlengo's has been serving handmade, family-owned gelato and Italian ice in Chicagoland since 1983.

Zarlengo's Italian Ice Pop - Mango

The OG Italian ice flavor from Zarlengo's, made with real lemons. Zarlengo's has been serving handmade, family-owned gelato and Italian ice in Chicagoland since 1983.

Zarlengo's Italian Ice Pop - Lemon

Rich, creamy ice cream made with a blend of peanut butter, caramel, chocolate, and bits of crunchy pretzel. The perfect salty-and-sweet treat.

High Five stans, this one's for you. This misunderstood candy bar is made even more phenomenal with Jeni's silky smooth sweet cream. And with all real ingredients, it's the most pure and tasty candy bar-inspired ice cream we've ever had.

Jeni's Ice Cream - High Five Candy Bar

Online Only

Organic sweet cream ice cream with crumbled creme cookies mixed in. No artificial flavors, sweeteners, or colors. Non-GMO. Made in Oregon.

Alden's uses free-range-raised cows for a creamier, silkier texture that you can taste the difference in. Paired with organic ingredients, zero artificial additives, and one-of-a-kind flavor combos, we feel good about eating this ice cream for more ways than one.

Alden's - Cookies N Cream Ice Cream 48 oz

Organic, decadent chocolate ice cream, with rich chocolate chips mixed in. No artificial flavors, sweeteners, or colors. Non-GMO. Made in Oregon.

Alden's - Chocolate Chocolate Chip Ice Cream 48 oz

Organic mint ice cream with thinly shaved chocolate chips mixed in. No artificial flavors, sweeteners, or colors. Non-GMO. Made in Oregon.

Alden's - Mint Chip Ice Cream 48 oz

Organic, rick, silky vanilla ice cream. No artificial flavors, sweeteners, or colors. Non-GMO.

Primary Navigation

Other Ways to Shop

Ship Anywhere

Same Day Gifts

Gift Cards

Nationwide Delivery

Get the App

Discover More
with the App

Search

Double, triple scoop on-demand.

Good stuff in store

@foxtrotmarket